Showing posts with label Balthasar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Balthasar. Show all posts

Sunday, October 30, 2022

BACK TO BALTHASAR

This will be the first foray into one of the controversial propositions of Hans Urs von Balthasar as expounded in his book Dare We Hope.

In the opening chapter Balthasar presents two theses that introduce the discussions to follow in his book.

1.

Balthasar presents several Bible passages referring to a Christian being under judgement and having to choose between good or evil, life or death, mercy and judgement. I leave it to the reader to read these passages.

James 2:13; Deuteronomy 30:15; Jeremiah 21:8; Proverbs 12:28 L X X; Matthew 7:13 f.; 2 Peter 2:15; Didache 1:1; Barnabas 18-20.

He then asks:

“The question is whether God, with respect to his plan of salvation, ultimately depends, and wants to depend, upon man's choice; or whether his freedom, which wills only salvation and is absolute, might not remain above things human, created and, therefore, relative."

 2.

"One can also approach this in another way, and we will see that Anselm does so: assuming that men can be divided into those who are just and those who are unjust, can one likewise, then, divide the divine qualities in such a way as to leave mercy on one side and (punitive) justice on the other? And since the two cannot, as on Calderon’s stage, enter into noble competition with each other, it will probably have to be as described in a Spanish work on dogmatics [De Novissimis, Jose F. Sagues]: 'a healing punishment issues from sheer mercy' (this probably refers to Purgatory); 'a vengeful punishment [poena vindicative] from pure justice, and this corresponds strictly to the offense' (this refers to hell). Thus, where God's mercy (which is obviously taken as finite here) wears thin, it remains for "pure justice" to exert itself. Now, since precisely this sort of assumption that divine qualities are finite is not acceptable, a dispute arises about whether one who is under judgment, as a Christian, can hope for all men.”

Quoting Balthasar, “I ventured to answer this affirmatively”. This begins a defense of his conclusion as well as the reasons his detractors disagree.

Sunday, January 5, 2020

Unless You Become Like This Child



from "Unless You Become Like This Child", page 22-24

"so it is with all other attributes needed to children: all of them are modeled on the wholesome exchange of love between the primarily giving love of the mother and the primarily received love the child. For the child it is natural to receive good gifts, and so docility, obedience, trust and sweet surrender are not for him virtues to be expressly achieved but the most unreflectedly natural things in the world. This is so to such an extent that the child adopts the mothers giving attitude unquestioningly as the right one, and he gives spontaneously when he has something to give. He shows his little treasures without hiding any of them; he wants to share her because he has experienced sharing as a form of goodness. The fact that he can make this attitude his own presupposes that he does not need to distinguish between the giver and the gift, since both at the mother's breast and in all other things given him the two are one: in the gift the child directly recognizes the love of the giver."

Balthasar takes this idyllic state of unity and introduces the effects of the human ego on this unitive love.

“It is the expressly perceivable egoism of the giver (Lk. 11:13) that results in the gift’s no longer being understood as the image of the giver: only then does the inclination to private possession become split in the child from its use as possible gift. Then we see vanish the spontaneous seeking of refuge in the place of protection and obedience as the immediate response to the “fostering “ source ; only then does concrete “fosterance” (auctoritas, from augere: “to make grow”, “to foster”) become abstract, legal “authority”.

Now Balthasar speaks to a important contemorary aspect of the civil culture and its role in developing the individuals' primal concept of love.

“Here arises the burning question whether the ruling, concrete authority of the parents of the family in regard to the children is something preliminary which is then enhanced to the seemingly all-encompassing and definitive authority of the state or of society, whose fostering care replaces that of the family. … But the fourth commandment of the Mosaic Decalogue stands opposed to this confiscation of the individual by the state, and it is a commandment that Christ reaffirms and which enjoins on adults, too, the respectful love of children for parents. Even when the educational element of the parents’ authority disappears as the children come of age, this does not abolish the original relationship of giving and responding personal love between children and parents.”
Near the end of this chapter of the book Balthasar gives a beautiful expression of one aspect of the doctrine of the communion of saints.

“… when children grow up and themselves become mothers and fathers … they will have an active experience of “archetypal identity”, still they will not be able to dissociate it from the passive form of it they had once experienced. The experience immerses them in the great stream of memory of generations whom they cannot cease to thank for their existence and whose past becomes for them the present, to the extent that, along with their progeny, they look out toward the future.”


Thursday, December 26, 2019

Unless You Become Like This Child

To follow up on he post of 12/21/2019 we continue with von Balthasar's reflection on being a child.

"... for a child, his parents' concrete love is not at first separable from God [see post of November 22, 2017 here ]; if everything follows an even course, this difference must be tenderly shown to him by his parents' humility and their own dependency on God. If this occurs as it should, the "archetypical; identity" will once again be confirmed for him in expanded form. The child will see clearly that love is realized only in reciprocity, in an oppositeness that is encounter and not opposition, a relationship that is held together in its very difference by the spirit of love and that, far from being endangered by mutuality, is rather strengthened by it. Love, too, is what enables the child to experience its absolute neediness as some thing other than a threat, since it is lived as the situation in which the mother's ever-latent love may be realized always anew.

The "archetypical identity", which we discover in creatures within a clear separation of persons who are held together by love, is a creaturely imago trinitatis ...."

Unless You Become Like This Child, Hans Urs von Balthasar, pp. 18-19

Saturday, December 21, 2019

On the Becoming of a Child


Image result for child jesus Balthasar, early in his short essay on becoming a child, takes us to the most intimate of our connections, the creative ability of God. The mystery into which his contemplation takes the reader is portrayed as the sacred union of God and mankind and reflected in this union is the sanctity  of the the union of man and woman. Contemplating this collaboration between God and mankind and God’s highest forms of creation, man and woman, we can appreciate God’s plan of creation with wonder and awe. Yet, we in our hubris and self-reliance reduce our sexuality by considering this magnificent gift to be just another form of recreation or make of it a merely physical process that can be manipulated to cater to our desires and whims. In so doing the sacred nature of the mystery loses its hold on our spirit.

Quoting from the essay:

Nevertheless, there does exist the sphere in which every person born possesses an archetypical model in keeping with which he is to direct his conscious life, surely following the course of his existence into the future but always with the memory of his origins before him.

Between the mother and the child she bears in her womb there exists an "archetypical identity", a unity which by no means is purely "natural", "physiological" or "unconscious": the child is already itself, it is already something "other" than the mother because it derives from the man's seed as much as from her. She had to conceive in order for the child to come to be in her, to come out of her most intimate being, as of course the father too had to receive from his wife in order to become fruitful in her. They had to be "two in one flesh", with mutual gratitude, in order to be able to procreate and love the new life that surpasses them both, the new life that will owe its existence to both of them together but for which they, together, will always have to be thankful in the site of the absolute creative Power that transcends them: "Children are a gift of the Lord" (Ps 127:3). Neither father nor mother would pretend that their contribution has given the child its spirit, its freedom, its immediacy with God.

Unless You Become Like This Child, Hans Urs von Balthasar, pp. 15-16

Friday, October 11, 2019

Intrinsic Good


The Catholic Church lays out for us the concept of intrinsic evil. 
In Pope John Paul II's Encyclical, Veritatis Splendor, he offers the following definition.

80. Reason attests that there are objects of the human act which are by their nature "incapable of being ordered" to God, because they radically contradict the good of the person made in his image. These are the acts which, in the Church's moral tradition, have been termed "intrinsically evil" ("intrinsece malum"): they are such "always and per se," in other words, on account of their very object, and quite apart from the ulterior intentions of the one acting and the circumstances. Consequently, without in the least denying the influence on morality exercised by circumstances and especially by intentions, the Church teaches that "there exist acts which "per se" and in themselves, independently of circumstances, are always seriously wrong by reason of their object".


One might ask,"What then is 'intrinsic good'?" In the first volume of Theo-Logic Balthasar offers an idea of intrinsic goodness.

p.35 – “Thus, there may be people who … have become used to doubting the existence of intrinsic goodness.”

“If, however, such people come face to face with the evidence of a selfless act that another … performs for its own sake, and they realize by their own inward experience that the naked overcoming of self is a really attainable possibility, they … bow before the simple fact of goodness.”

Saturday, September 28, 2019

Balthasar' Theo-Logic

The following quote of Fr. Richard John Neuhaus is from the April 2006 edition of First Things and was the motivation for my interest in Balthasar.

"He went in for heavy-duty intellection that is sometimes ponderous and exhaustingly discursive, but always adorned with dazzling erudition and rewarding one's effort with scintillating insights of a frequently counter-intuitive nature. One spends pleasurable hours reading Balthasar not so much in an analytical mode as in surrendering oneself to the beauty of how his mind works and its adventurous probings of theological imagination. Reading Balthasar is in large part a meditative exercise bordering on the contemplative."

Once again I've gathered the fortitude to wade through more of Balthasar's "heavy duty intellection" in search of some "scintillating insights".

I don't know how scintillating one may find the quotes that follow. One may say, "Oh, yea, I knew that." But, have you ever attempted to put the ideas presented into your own words? Thanks to Hans Urs von Balthasar I am able to articulate some thing that I was previously able only to intuit.

From Theo-Logic Volume 1:Truth of the World


P.12 – “… the supernatural takes root in the deepest structures of being, leavens them through and through, and permeates them like a breath or an omnipresent fragrance.”

p.16-17 – “All of the perversions that human freedom can inflict upon being and its qualities always aim at one thing: the annihilation of the depth dimension of being, thanks to which being remains a mystery, even, indeed, precisely in its unveiling. The formula “A is nothing other than …” typifies this perversion, whatever the transcendental it affects. It is much rather the case that A is always “something other than …” Neither goodness nor beauty nor truth is exhausted by any definition; the multi-dimensional reality of the transcendentals can ever be flattened out by any kind of reduction, and there is no way to capture the mystery either of their existence or of their essence in a formula. Of course, the ultimate ground of the mysterious character inherent in the knowable is disclosed only when we recognize that every possible object of knowledge is creaturely, in other words, that its ultimate truth lies hidden in the mind of the Creator, who alone can speak the eternal name of things. …. It is God, then, who secures the transcendentals against all the assaults of human freedom – however much ruin this freedom might cause.

Monday, August 20, 2018

More from the Little Flower


Therese presents for me a new way to understand what Jesus meant in the story of the rich young man and his instruction to give all he has away. She along with Balthasar provides much to meditate on in two passages from Romans. Mining the thought of the Little Flower provides an inexhaustible source of golden wisdom. The text below in quotes, except for the Scripture quotes, is from the writings of St.Therese and the rest from Balthasar's Two Sisters in the Spirit (pp. 257- 259).


The mentality that confronts Therese so frequently in the Catholic asceticism of her day … is the Old Testament mentality of justification by works ….
This attitude assumes that man’s relations with God are based entirely upon justice, and this limited conception of justice … can only imagine one ideal – to step up one’s own achievements so as to produce a corresponding increase in God’s favors. But this ideal overlooks … the very basis and raison d’etre of God’s testament with the chosen people: Abraham’s faith, which implicitly includes hope and love as well.

God first revealed himself as the God of justice, not as the God of love. And besides wishing  to prepare humanity for love by means of the law, God also wished the failure of the law and its works to demonstrate what happens when men rely upon their own achievements apart from the Cross of Christ. (Rom 5:20)

Therese inserts her New Testament theology and asceticism at the exact point where the transition takes place. Her “little way” to “little sanctity” at first appears … as one way among many others and she contrasts it particularly with the “great ways” of the “great saints” …. These great saints have done mighty deeds for God, but they are so superior as to discourage Therese …. But the more she gets to know the little way, the more she realizes … that it is the only way.

… as time goes on and she assumes the role of David, armed with a sling and venturing into the open to attack the Goliath of “great sanctity”. “The great saints have gained heaven by their works; myself I wish to imitate the thieves, I wish to take it by a trick, a trick of love that will give me entry, me and other poor sinners.”

And what is this trick? “It is quite simple. Hold nothing back. Distribute your goods as soon as you get them …. If at the moment of death, I were to present my little coins to have them estimated at their true worth, our Lord would not fail to discover dross in them that I should certainly go and deposit in Purgatory.” And now she transfers  … her amused gaze … toward God, teasing the God of justice: “When I think of the good God’s statement: ‘I shall come soon and bring my reward with me, repaying everyone according to his works’, then I say to myself that he will find himself very much embarrassed with me, because I have no works! So he will not be able to repay me according to my works. Very well, then, I trust he will repay me according to his works.”

Therese is here preaching a lesson straight from the gospel of Paul: “Now to him that works, the reward is not reckoned according to grace but according to debt. But to him that works not, yet believes in him who justifies the ungodly, his faith is reputed to justice, according to the purpose of the grace of God” (Rom 4:4-5).

And: “ since all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God they are justified by his grace as a gift , through the redemption which is in Christ Jesus …. (Rom 3:23-24)

Sunday, August 12, 2018

Little Doctrines from the Little Flower

I am awed when I see the gift the "good God" had given St.Therese. What has taken me seventy-five years merely to appreciate, St.Therese so readily understood and practiced.
The following is from Two Sisters in the Spirit, by Hans Urs von Balthasar. The text below within quotation marks is taken from St.Therese's writings; all else is Balthasar's.

“Jesus does not demand great deeds but only gratitude and self-surrender. ‘I will not’ he says, ‘take the goats from out of your flocks, for all the beasts of the field are mine …. Shall I eat the flesh of bullocks, or shall I drink the blood of goats? Offer to God the sacrifice of praise and thanksgiving.’ See, then , all that Jesus lays claim to from us; he has no need of our works but only  of our love.”

It is generally recognized that “cosmetics for the soul”, “that overwrought, incessant measuring, counting, calculating, touching and examining one’s own ‘perfection’, that most dangerous distraction of attention from God to the ego under the pretext of tender conscience, and even humility”, constitute a special danger for those living the monastic life and, particularly for contemplatives, constitute the universal “temptation to perfection”

As a child Therese was trained to “collect” merit; Marie taught her to do so: “I can still hear you saying to me, ‘Look at the shopkeepers, how much trouble they give themselves to make money, whereas we can amass treasure for heaven without giving ourselves so much trouble; all we have to do is to gather diamonds with a rake’. And off I went, my heart filled with joy, overflowing with good resolutions.” And in her early letters, we see the child busy at this work of collecting: “every day I try to do all the ‘practices’ I can, and do my best not to let any opportunity pass. From the bottom of my heart, and as often as possible , I say the little prayers: they are sweet-scented like roses …, my thanks to Sister Therese of St. Augustine for her dear little rosary of practices….”

But gradually, without it being noticed, the meaning of the word changes and surrenders its kernel of Christian truth; the treasure is love, but love is the prodigality that knows neither to count nor reckon. “it’s very simple. Hold nothing back; distribute your goods as soon as you get them. As for myself. If I live to be eighty years old, I shall still be as poor. I do not know how to make economies; everything I have I give away immediately to buy souls.”


Progress does not come through acquisitions but through losing everything; it does not mean climbing, it means descending. A novice sighs: “When I think of everything I still have to acquire!” [Therese] “You mean, to lose! Jesus takes it upon himself to fill your soul in the measure that you rid it of your imperfections. I see that you have taken the wrong road; you will never arrive at the end of your journey. You are wanting to climb a great mountain, and the good God is trying to make you descend it; he is waiting for you at the fertile valley of humility.”


Wednesday, July 25, 2018

St. Therese on Saints

In his study of St. Therese in Two Sisters in the Spirit, Balthasar offers this characterization of St. Therese’s view of the vocation of the saints.


“The true saints are those whose ardor in their earthly mission is fed solely by the eternal, heavenly life that they have tasted but has been so painfully withdrawn. They do not turn their backs on the world in order to enjoy the rest of heaven in advance. Rather they live a life of intense longing and move the world by the strength of that heaven that has first been granted to them and then closed to them. They hang crucified between this world and the beyond; exiles from earth but not yet in their heavenly home, their position serves as a kind of pulpit, and their whole life is a sermon. It does not matter whether the preaching takes the form of action or contemplation – this decision is left to God; in both cases, their position is the same, stretched between earth and heaven. And the longer they hang there, the more intimate the presence of heaven within them, for nothing brings a person nearer to God than hanging there.” p. 212

Friday, July 7, 2017

God has begun to do something here that will not come to a stop until Golgotha

Hans Urs von Balthasar in volume six of The Glory of the Lord beautifully describes the Old Covenant, God’s relationship with his chosen people. A section of the volume is devoted to the messages of the prophets. One of the more moving is Balthasar’s exposition on Hosea. In a time when our sexual natures are being perverted and diminished to a merely functional instinct, Balthasar shows us how God uses Hosea to point to the divine in human sexuality and to the the divine compassion of our God.

In Hosea we are confronted with Israel’s infidelities.

1 Hear the word of the LORD, Israelites, for the LORD has a dispute with the inhabitants of the land: There is no fidelity, no loyalty, no knowledge of God in the land. 2 Swearing, lying, murder, stealing and adultery break out; bloodshed follows bloodshed. 3 Therefore the land dries up, and everything that dwells in it languishes: The beasts of the field, the birds of the air, and even the fish of the sea perish. (Ch 4)

11 … Aged wine and new wine take away understanding. 12 My people consult their piece of wood, and their wand makes pronouncements for them, for the spirit of prostitution has led them astray; they prostitute themselves, forsaking their God. 13 On the mountaintops they offer sacrifice and on the hills they burn incense, beneath oak and poplar and terebinth, because of their pleasant shade. Therefore your daughters prostitute themselves, and your daughters-in-law commit adultery. (Ch 4)

God’s wrath is fired up:

4 I, the LORD, am your God, since the land of Egypt; Gods apart from me you do not know; there is no savior but me. 5 I fed you in the wilderness, in the parched land. 6 When I fed them, they were satisfied; when satisfied, they became proud, therefore they forgot me. 7 So, I will be like a lion to them, like a leopard by the road I will keep watch. 8 I will attack them like a bear robbed of its young, and tear their hearts from their breasts; I will devour them on the spot like a lion, as a wild animal would rip them open. 9 I destroy you, Israel! who is there to help you? (Ch 13)



Balthasar, GL Vol VI, p 239
“When the people ‘departs’ from Yahweh to ‘go whoring’ this ends in the drastic situation in which sexuality becomes central, a situation that shows the depth of the abandoned and desecrated covenant in a completely new light. And although the first sin of this kind is to be dated back in the scene in Baal-Peor on the edge of the wilderness, it is only here that the unheard-of consequences are seen, when God takes hold of the sexual dimension of his prophet Hosea in order to portray himself therein in his supra-sexual relationship to Israel. God embraces the sphere of male and female gift of self in the flesh, in order to make use of it as an instrument of revelation on the basis of the total obedience of the prophet, the exact opposite of what the people had done …. “

Hosea Ch 2
2 When the LORD began to speak with Hosea, the LORD said to Hosea: Go, get for yourself a woman of prostitution and children of prostitution, for the land prostitutes itself, turning away from the LORD. 3 So he went and took Gomer, daughter of Diblaim; and she conceived and bore him a son. 4 Then the LORD said to him: Give him the name “Jezreel, [God sows] for in a little while I will punish the house of Jehu for the bloodshed at Jezreel and bring to an end the kingdom of the house of Israel; 5 on that day I will break the bow of Israel in the valley of Jezreel.
6 She conceived again and bore a daughter. The LORD said to him: Give her the name “Not-Pitied (Lo-ruhamah), for I will no longer feel pity for the house of Israel: rather, I will utterly abhor them. 7 Yet for the house of Judah I will feel pity; I will save them by the LORD, their God; but I will not save them by bow or sword, by warfare, by horses or horsemen.
8 After she weaned Not-Pitied, she conceived and bore a son. 9 Then the LORD said: Give him the name “Not-My-People,” for you are not my people, and I am not “I am” for you.

Hosea Ch 3
1 Again the LORD said to me: Go, love a woman who is loved by her spouse but commits adultery; Just as the LORD loves the Israelites, though they turn to other gods and love raisin cakes. 2 So I acquired her for myself for fifteen pieces of silver and a homer and a lethech of barley. 3 Then I said to her: “You will wait for me for many days; you will not prostitute yourself  or belong to any man; I in turn will wait for you (not come to you).”

.. it is thus that God wishes to have his relationship to the people embodied. In both cases, Hosea’s sexual conduct is determined by obedience to God and by renunciation: both in the exercise of his marital rights, which humbles him, and in the non-exercise of the marital relationship. His love and the form which it takes in each case are prescribed for him and his obedience makes it possible for a bridge to be built where this had seemed impossible: the Canaanite emphasis on sexuality is integrated into an entire scheme which utterly supersedes it, and thus God’s relationship to the people is disclosed – for the first time in the history of Israel – as love, burning and tender love, because this love appears in the deepest humiliation. Through this, with disconcerting suddenness, we are given a proleptic view of the final act of the drama: that which is divine in God, his glory, becomes understandable as love, so that everything that God will undertake vis-à-vis his people – including the most terrible measures – is necessarily set under the sign of love.  GL Vol VI, p. 240-241
       

Thanks to the mediating obedience of the prophet in the most intimate sphere of human life, there occurs in Hosea a disclosure of the heart of God which is new and unheard-of when compared with all that has gone before. In pure obedience, Hosea overcomes ab intra the world of the mythical deities which has fallen prey to sexuality, and is able, precisely through this to bring to light the love of God which is supra-sexual. ‘God suffers under Israel’s false love affairs’; he cannot bear them, and we see him as it were wavering between mercy on the guilty wife and the necessity of punishing her ruthlessly. “What shall I do with you, O Ephraim?’ (6:4) It is love that wins the day: ‘How can I give you up, O Ephraim! … My heart recoils within me, my compassion grows warm and tender, I will not execute my fierce anger, I will not again destroy Ephraim; for I am God and not man, the Holy One in your midst’ (11:8-9) Although the word is not used , it is the kabod of Yahweh that reveals itself in a new, incomprehensible depth as the love that lies beyond wrath and has to do with God’s being God, with his absoluteness. But this unattainably transcendent element is at the same time profaned by human beings in the world and humiliated by them, since its love carries it to the point of defencelessness. The adulteress is purchased …so that she can sit still beside the Lord once more. And he ‘allures her seductively’ (2:16) so that he may speak to her heart. Hosea is commanded to ‘love’ this woman: this is the word that expresses the love between a man and a woman (‘hb), with the difference that in him it is selflessly helpful while in her it is lascivious and full of desire. Hosea’s message meets with no greater acceptance than that of the major literary prophets: ‘The prophet is a fool! The man of the spirit is mad!’ (9:7); he is expelled from the land. Even in this fate, he declares something of the ‘foolish’ God’s love (1 Cor 1) as he runs after a faithless harlot. God has begun to do something here that will not come to a stop until Golgotha. GL Vol VI, p.244




Thursday, January 26, 2017

The Revival of Israel

John the Baptist - Rodin
In Vol. VII of The Glory of the Lord Balthasar's prelude speaks of the the revival of his people from their long exile after the destruction of the temple. His description of the Baptist as the forerunner of Christ and the way in which the news of the coming Kingdom was to occur is quite moving. Pay attention as well to Balthasar's use of  various scriptural sources to weave his exposition of John's mission. It would be difficult to use scripture in this way with merely a cursory or even very attentive reading.

"… Israel must set out afresh, for since the exile it has existed no more. The messenger, sent out by God before his face in Malachi (3:1) has also the commission to ‘turn again’ the hearts of the fathers to the sons, and of the sons to the fathers (4:6); this is taken over by the grandson of Ben Sirach and receives explanation and expansion in the ‘restoration of the (twelve) tribes of Jacob’ (Sir 48:10) The word ‘restoration‘ (apokatastasis) is applied to the Baptist by Jesus himself (Mk 9:12; cf. Lk 1:17) before it is applied to Jesus (as his own forerunner for the day of the Parousia) in Peter’s sermon (Acts 3:21).


God’s word comes upon John in the wilderness. He was of priestly descent, but the name which the angel ordered to be given him indicated that he had been chosen out of all the priesthood of the Old Testament. His dwelling in the wilderness was not like that of the men of Qumran, but was in solitude, ascetical clothing and extreme frugality; nor was his message like that of the political messianic movements which mostly started out from the wilderness, for his message was one of pure salvation history. This permits the origins of Israel in the concept of the wilderness to awaken once more. The wilderness is the place to which God wishes to woo back the apostate Israel, as a bridegroom his beloved, so that he may speak to her heart there (Hos 2:16); but not without 'stripping her naked and making her like a wilderness' (Hos 2:5). The wilderness is the dreadful and glorious state of being handed over to God: the greatest temptation (among demons and wild beasts) and the greatest nuptial intimacy (Jer 2:2). The 'journey through the wilderness' is unavoidable for Jesus, but also for Christians (1 Cor 10:6; Heb 3:8-11), for whom it is the place where God's Word like a two edged sword pierces to the inmost division of joints and marrow, thoughts and intentions, and lays all open before him (Heb 4:12f). It is the place where one learns to pray and where one can then teach others to pray (Lk 11-1). It is the place where there are no fixed points, but where only a nomadic existence is permitted upon earth (Lk 3:3), such as the existence of which Israel once led under God's guidance, and which Jesus too, driven by the Spirit, will lead once more (‘nowhere to lay his head’, Mt 11:18)."

Tuesday, January 24, 2017

Our Call to Love

Following is an excerpt from The Christian State of Life by
Hans Urs von Balthasar. Much of the chapter this is taken from has been left out as I just wanted to capture what in my opinion are the highlights of his meditation. I can forward a copy to anyone who would like the entire chapter.

“Master, which is the great commandment in the law?” He answers them, “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with thy whole heart, with all thy soul, and with all thy mind. This is the greatest and the first commandment. And the second is like it. Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself. On these two commandments depend the whole law and the prophets” (Mt 22:36-40).

… the commandments are so completely contained in the dual commandment of love of God and love of neighbor that whoever keeps this commandment, on which the whole law and the prophets depend, has done all that is necessary.

Without love, on the other hand, even the perfect observance of the commandments is meaningless and useless …. this commandment is so unconditional and inflexible in its formulation, so transcendent of time and so apparently immutable in the face of every human ability or inability to observe it, every hope and doubt, every striving and failure, even every conviction, that no one on earth can seriously claim to have observed it in its entirety; that we are, in fact, more likely to regard it as an expression of wishful thinking, of an ideal but unattainable polestar riding high above the lowlands of human wretchedness, than as the commandment it actually is.

But the Lord does not call this commandment a wish on the part of God or a recommendation … he does not speak of it as a steep path beside which there are other—easier—ones.

“A new commandment I give you, that you love one another: that as I have loved you, you also love one another. By this will all men know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another” (Jn 13:34-35).

“This is my commandment, that you love one another as I have loved you” (Jn 15:12), it has also become the criterion of our love of God: “He who has my commandments and keeps them”—precisely these commandments of love—“he it is who loves me” (Jn 14:21).

If we do not love, we have so completely failed to fulfill our calling that we are dead even though our bodies are still alive: “He who does not love abideth in death” (1 Jn 3:14).

Thus the principle is affirmed that the calling to love is an absolute one, admitting of no exception, and so ineluctable that failure to observe it is tantamount to total corruption. Let there be no doubt. We are here to love—to love God and to love our neighbor. Whoever will unravel the meaning of existence must accept this fundamental principle from whose center light is shed on all the dark recesses of our lives. For this love to which we are called is not a circumscribed or limited love, not a love defined, as it were, by the measure of our human weakness. It does not allow us to submit just one part of our lives to its demands and leave the rest free for other pursuits; it does not allow us to dedicate just one period of our lives to it and the rest, if we will, to our own interests. The command to love is universal and unequivocal. It makes no allowances. It encompasses and makes demands upon everything in our nature: “with thy whole heart, with all thy soul, and with all thy mind”.

… this commandment takes no heed of our human potential for observing it. All that is important is that it be observed; how this is to be done is a second question with which the first is not concerned. If we are unable to observe it by our own strength, God will not fail to give us the means to do so. But one thing God will not do: He will not accommodate his great commandment to our human insufficiency. For he knows there is only one thing that love cannot endure: to have limits set to it.

Love has its origin in God, who is eternal and boundless life. A love that is not active, that is not ready to prove itself in ever new and different ways, is not love.

It can never mean that it has reached the limit of its capacity to love … and can now find comfort in the thought that it has fulfilled its obligation to love. If such a thought enters the love of two individuals, their love is already growing cold.

Love can never give itself sufficiently, can never exhaust its ingenuity in preparing new joys for the beloved, is never so satisfied with itself and its deeds that it does not look for new proofs of love, is never so familiar with the person of the beloved that it does not crave the wonderment of new knowledge.

“Obligation”, then, is a word that pure love does not know. Or rather: its “obligation” is always a “choice”. It experiences the necessity it is under of loving the beloved as the highest and most perfect freedom—a freedom not to be exchanged for all the goods of this world.

What lover would not gladly lay the whole world at the feet of the beloved? If we love, we do not know the difference between command and wish. The wish of the beloved is our command. We forestall every unspoken desire on the lips of the beloved and fulfill it.

We are not asking here whether this is the nature of human beings or whether and to what extent they are capable of loving in this way ….

… in every purest expression of it, we encounter anew the mystery of self-giving. For the sake of the beloved, love would gladly renounce all its possessions if it could thereby enrich the beloved.
We cannot perceive of love as a merely penultimate good of our spirit, cannot reserve for it a circumscribed place in our soul, cannot assign to it but a limited portion of our strength.

The spirit of love is a spirit of self-giving and, consequently, of “choice”. It is nothing but self-giving. For this reason, it needs no other law than itself; all other laws are subsumed, fulfilled, transcended in the one law of love.

von Balthasar, Hans Urs. The Christian State of Life (Kindle Locations 176-415). Ignatius Press. Kindle Edition.

Friday, January 6, 2017

Irenaeus

“My entire period of study in the Society of Jesus was a grim struggle with the dreariness of theology, with what men had made out of the glory of revelation. I could not endure this presentation of the Word of God and wanted to lash out with the fury of Samson: I felt like tearing down, with Samson’s own strength, the whole temple and bury myself beneath the rubble. But it was like this because, despite my sense of vocation, I wanted to carry out my own plans, and was living in a state of unbounded indignation. I told almost no one about this. [My teacher at the time Erich] Przywara understood everything; [to him] I did not have to say anything. Otherwise there was no one who could understand me.”


These thoughts of Hans Urs von Balathasar are taken from his introduction to Adrienne von Speyr’s journals. His feelings reflect what he saw as dry Thomist theology that lacked the passion and the fire inherent in the Word.

In Vol. II of the Glory of the Lord Balthasar selects five theologies that represent what he sees as preceding the branching off of the disciplines of theology and philosophy; Irenaeus, Augustine, Denys, Anselm and Bonaventure. In Vol. III he selects seven whose theologies were developed after the split of the two areas of study; Dante, St. John of the Cross, Pascal, Hamann, Soloviev, Hopkins and Peguy. He selects these as representative of those theologies that project the fire and passion, what he termed “the glory of the Lord”,  he felt was lacking in the theology being taught at the time.

An example of what he saw in Irenaeus is taken from Vol. II P.64 – 65:

“ …. Irenaeus is totally amazed at the miracle of the human body made alive by the soul. It is for him the most fundamental example of what distinguishes the creature: its being formed by God's hand: `The flesh is not without a share in the artistic wisdom and power of God, because God's power, which bestows life, is made perfect in weakness (2 Cor 12.9), that is, in the flesh."" Strange and impressive exegesis! `The flesh is devised to be receptive and to be able to contain the power of God, since in the beginning it received the art of God, and one part became an eye for seeing, another an ear for hearing, another a hand for feeling and making, another nerves, tensed in all direction and holding the limbs together, another arteries and veins for the circulation of the blood and the soul-breath, another in turn different internal organs, and another blood, the link between body and soul. It is indeed impossible to describe the whole masterly structure of elements which makes up man; it did not come into being without greatness and wisdom. But what shares in the art and wisdom of God also shares in his power.'

And from p.74-75:


 “This is the source of the central concept of `glory' as the mutual glorification of God and man. Man, who preserves God's art in himself and obediently opens himself to its dispos­ing, glorifies the artist and the artist glorifies himself in his work. `You do not create God; God creates you. Therefore if you are God's work, wait patiently for the hand of your artist, who does everything in due proportion, and in due proportion as regards you who are being made. Offer him your heart soft and pliable, and preserve the form which the artist forms out of you: preserve it by keeping yourself moist, so that you do not dry out and harden and lose the trace of his fingers. Keeping the form that has been impressed on you, you will move towards perfection, for the clay that is in you will be hidden by the artist.   His hand has created the substance in you, and now it will cover you inside and out with pure gold and silver and beautify you so much that "even the king will lust after your beauty" (Ps 45:11)”

Monday, January 2, 2017

Soul Stirring Rhetoric

A formative influence on Von Balthasar was the Jesuit theologian Erich Przywara (1889-1972). Edward Oakes’ book Patterns of Redemption addresses Przywara’s influence on von Balthasar and uses the following quotation from Przywara’s writings. The passion of Fr. Przywara and his student can be glimpsed in the following reflecting on the mission of the prophets.


“The prophets whom the angels seized up into heaven and brought before the Throne of Glory to experience how much they had to “suffer for His Name” could only remain alone. Alone in the fullness of mission-determined communication, distant in the confusion of close-order battle with friend and foe, with one’s own people and with foreigners, forced into the distance for the sake of discerning the spirits as commanded, but only by the virtue of first having been touched with the all-consuming fire that would mark them henceforward and which they would never forget. Their Word burns: it does not baptize in water but in spirit and fire. Zeal for God’s house consumes them. They themselves are certainly fire. And when – misunderstood and rejected of men, despised, mocked and betrayed by family and neighbors – they gave their soul, fatigued unto death, back to God, then it can be that He Who Consumes with Fire will send them his fiery chariot to call them home.”

Thursday, November 24, 2016

Back to Balthasar

It has been a long break from my Balthasar project. In 2007 I began this project with the intent of reading his trilogy, The Glory of the Lord, Theo-Drama, and Theo-Logic. Life events have gotten in the way. Yet Hans Urs von Balthasar continues to tug on my spiritual strings and so I return, picking up where I left off, at Volume 7 of The Glory of the Lord. I pray the Lord provides me the time and the determination to complete my project.

In the prelude to Volume 7 Balthasar describes it's purpose. He describes this work as unconventional and seemingly "amateurish" to professional theologians, but states, “ … it is more important to get at all costs to a point from which we can see the essential matter, than to lay down orderly roads that lead to that point.”

“It is considerably harder to clear a path in the new covenant to the prospect we seek, than in the old covenant; the latter unfolds in a history that can be followed clearly through centuries, but the new covenant bunches everything together into the shortest space of time, in the midpoint of which stands the breakdown-point which can be delimited in external chronology as the ‘Triduum Mortis’, but which internally means that time has come to an end and that there is a new beginning such that all temporal categories of ‘end’, ‘midpoint’, and ‘beginning’ are shattered; and this means that not only the main subject (the theological content of the fate of Jesus), but also the position of the existentially involved observer (the Christian who seeks to understand his faith, in order to live it) slip away at the very point where they ought to be made secure. But it is not our concern to get a secure place to stand, but rather to get sight of what cannot be securely grasped, and this must remain the event of Jesus Christ; woe to the Christian who would not stand daily speechless before this event! If this event truly is what the church believes, then it can be mastered through no methodology …." (Bold emphasis mine)

For an explanation of the Balthasar's concept of Triduum Mortis see his work, Mysterium Paschale. 







Saturday, June 4, 2016

More on Sin from Balthasar by Oakes

"It is just that the saints are given to see without veils what the rest of us would just as soon not care to know."

Hans Urs von Balthasar makes this statement in his book on Karl Barth (The Theology of  Karl Barth, by Hans Urs von Balthasar, translated by Edward T. Oakes, Ignatius Press, 1992, p. 375.) Balthasar goes on to remind us of the communal nature of sin; something we intuitively know to be true, but somehow fail to keep in the fore when considering the behavior of our brethren. 

"Here we confront the mystery of man's solidarity in sin. Every personal sin is also a community sin: both in the sense of impairing the community but also being caused, to some extent, by the community’s sin. Far from circumscribing sin, it makes it weightier, putting new burdens of responsibility in the sinner. And since the effects of evil committed and good deeds left undone increase and multiply relentlessly, our debt is not paid off when our personal guilt is forgiven."

"The just man, to the extent that he shares an active portion in the holiness of the Redeemer, also receives a more active portion in the task of bearing a guilt not his own, thereby sharing in the very work of redemption. This finally reaches the point where he can no longer distinguish whether he is suffering for his own sins or for that of others. For Christ himself, when he was hanged on the Cross, no longer wished to make this distinction either. He endured God's malediction against sin, suffering vicariously for us all. And, because of Christ, the sinner who wants to share in the sufferings can no longer make this distinction either. The true follower of Christ joins Christ in that darkness that is all the more bitter because he knows he can never suffer alongside of Christ. No, this suffering highlights how deeply bound he is in solidarity with all his fellow sinners, who are jointly responsible for the cross of Christ."

Sunday, January 10, 2016

Balthasar - A Dialectic Between Sin and the Cross


In the previous post Balthasar speaks of  our participation in the cross of Christ, "Such participation, as the Lord wishes, can go to the extremes of powerlessness, spiritual darkness, forsakeness and rejection; since these things are sharing in the cross ..." He here indicates the Ignatian roots of his spirituality. He goes on in the following to further delve into St. Ignatius' exercises as we contemplate our own sin and the sin of the world.

from pp. 298-300
But there is a dialectic in our contemplation of sin in the light of the cross: only by looking at my Redeemer can I understand the extent of what I have done. In the face of redeeming love I am pierced through by a nameless terror: I might be, indeed I am a murderer of Eternal Love; no excuses are of any avail; I deserve unconditional damnation. Beholding the handiwork of ultimate love between Father, Son and Spirit, performed for me, loveless as I am, I begin to understand that I do not belong among them, that I do not have love and thus I'm deserving of eternal wrath. Indeed, I merit destruction and banishment from the whole divine order:

"A shout of astonishment and profound love, as I think how every created thing has not refused to keep me alive. The angels, the sword of God's justice, have put up with me, protected me, prayed for me: the saints have gone on praying and interceding on my behalf: the sky, the sun, the moon, the stars, the natural elements, the fruits of the earth, birds, fish, the whole animal kingdom…; Why is not the very earth opened to swallow me, creating new hells for my eternal torment?" (Exercises, 60)  [St. Ignatius]… does not neglect to put the contemplation of general and personal sinfulness in the theological context of the redemption. Each individual reflection leads up to the Colloquies with the merciful Lord "hanging on the Cross before me", whose love shows me what I have (not) done for Christ, what I am (not) doing for Christ, and what I shall (not) do for Christ. And it is within this “kind of talk friends have with one another, or perhaps like the way a servant speaks to his master" (Exercises, 54) that I become aware that I have thoroughly deserved hell. Unless it acquires a profile by being contrasted with redeeming love, the idea of hell will remain fantastic and imaginary, impossible for us to take absolutely seriously in our prayer. But, once it has this firm outline, it is what "stops the mouth" (Rom. 3:10) of the sinner who is always trying to find some reason why God cannot really abandon a man.

Friday, January 8, 2016

Reflection - A Coincidence of Events



Of course, Christmas is a joyous occasion. Jesus Christ is born. God has taken on human form. God condescended to become one of us. As difficult a concept as this is to understand, one cannot help but be gladdened, even flattered, that this is what our Faith asks us to believe. Yet, the postings of January regarding Balthasar's last chapter in his book Prayer, and two sermons serving as readings for the Office of Readings for Friday, January 8 (from Christian Prayer: The Liturgy of the Hours, Catholic Book Publishing Co.), indicate that this is not a complete picture of the joy and the peace that we celebrate at Christmas.


In a Christmas day sermon Leo the Great closes the sermon with the following:
"Through the sacrament of baptism you have become a temple of the Holy Spirit. Do not drive away so great a guest by evil conduct and become again a slave to the devil, for your liberty was bought by the blood of Christ."


Peter Chrysologus in a sermon entitled "The sacrament of Christ's incarnation", ends his sermon thus:
"and so Christ is born that by his birth he might restore our nature. He became a child, was fed, and grew that he might inaugurate the one perfect age to remain forever as he had created it. He supports man that man might no longer fall. And the creature he had formed of earth he now makes heavenly; and what he had endowed with the human soul he now vivifies to become a heavenly spirit. In this way he fully raised man to God, and left in him neither sin, nor death, nor travail, nor pain, nor anything earthly, with the grace of our Lord Christ Jesus…. Amen."
 


In the coincidence of reading these sermons and their connection with Balthasar's reflections on the Cross and Resurrection it became clear to me that the birth of Jesus, the joy of the Christmas season and the love and peace it promises, is not complete until we make that connection between Christ's birth and the birth of the new man, his death on the Cross and our death to ourselves, and Jesus’ resurrection and our resurrection to that divinized recreation.

Thursday, January 7, 2016

"Prayer" - von Balthasar continues


Its one thing to read St. Paul's letters and it is totally different to see their theological fabric. Balthasar weaves his discussion on the contemplation of the cross and resurrection with words from St. Paul's various letters. In so doing he brings new dimensions to St. Paul's letters and new insights into our participation in the mystery of the cross.

More from the last chapter of Prayer:
It could be said that the center of Paul’s entire theology is the fact that the balance of the old and the new aeon, the first and second Adam, cross and resurrection, fear and hope, has been tipped in favor of the resurrection. Moreover, the first of each of these pairs is embraced by the second; the cross in the Christian life is borne by the power of the resurrection: “We are afflicted in every way, but not crushed; perplexed, but not driven to despair; persecuted, but not forsaken; struck down, but not destroyed; always carrying in the body the death of Jesus, so that the life of Jesus may also be manifested in our bodies …. So we do not lose heart. (2 Cor.4:8-10, 16-18)


…. Thus Paul always speaks of his own sufferings … as a demonstration of the power of the Risen Lord, never as being in competition with the Lord’s passion. …. Thus the servant has no reason for boasting; he only does his duty (1 Cor. 9:16) in allowing the Father to reveal his Son in him (Gal. 1:16). All this “bearing death in the body” is the result of a contemplation of the resurrection in which we are assimilated more and more efficaciously to the glory of the Son, who transforms the beholder into himself: “We all with unveiled face, beholding the glory of the Lord, are being changed into his likeness from one degree of glory to another; for this comes from the Lord who is the Spirit” (2 Cor. 3:18) pp. 296-7 

Wednesday, January 6, 2016

"Prayer", Hans Urs von Balthasar

When searching my small library for a book, I cannot help but pass by my shelf of von Balthsar's writings. His seventeen volume Trilogy, The Glory of the Lord, Theo Drama, and Theo Logic are neatly lined up in a row. I've only made it to Volume 7 of The Glory of the Lord. Yet, each time I pass my eyes over this shelf I invariably grab a small paperback volume entitled Prayer. 
This most recent time I pulled it off the shelf, fully forgetting my reason for scanning my book shelves, and I began to reread some of the book. Now, someone told me once, (my spiritual director I think) that it is not the number of books that you read that is a most important thing, but, the number of books that you re-read. I have not re-read the entire book. Each time I pick it up I go to certain sections that struck me as particularly meaningful or especially beautifully phrased.

I offer here a brief snippet from the very last chapter in the book, Cross and Resurrection
.
But “God shows his love for us in that while we were yet sinners Christ died for us … while we were enemies we were reconciled to God by the death of his Son” (Rom.5:8,10) … The sentence which in principle determined our fate was performed upon Jesus Christ on behalf of sinners: in him we were crucified and condemned to death; in him we were made the recipients of grace and adopted as children. In him and without any activity on our part, God’s anger toward us has changed into tender, caring love. All this has become a reality, in and through Christ, in the Father’s heaven: our task is to let it come true in all its fullness in our temporal existence on earth.

In the New Covenant “what we ought to do” follows from “what we are”. We are justified and should act accordingly. We have died with Christ, we have been buried and raised with him, and this should determine our behavior: we should no longer live in sin; the “old man” is dead and we should actually regard him as such, daily encountering his resistance to the death sentence served upon him, making him die daily (Rom 6). pp. 295-296